In my research on the impact of digital platforms on relationships and communication, as well as in my job teaching young people, I frequently come across variations of the same lament: Most days, it feels like the only interactions I have are with machines. Even when buying groceries, we’re in the self-check-out line, not talking to a human cashier. The desire to forge real relationships, not just online ones, is legitimate and worthy of action. But I also tell my students who fret too much over this that they may be missing the forest for the trees.
This idea that even though you are connecting online, you are not actually connecting “in real life” isn’t necessarily supported by the evidence. There is a lot of positivity that comes from interacting through the internet, whether by sending your best friend TikToks, participating in an online fandom, or engaging in spaces like #BookTok. We shouldn’t look at those interactions as failing to connect—they are simply connections that do not happen face-to-face. Beating yourself up for not talking to the cashier misses the point.
People also seem to judge themselves too harshly in the performativity versus authenticity debate. But as the scholar and philosopher Judith Butler articulated, we are all performative by virtue of being part of society. Authenticity and performativity are a false binary. Only you know whether or not you are being authentic to yourself.
That said, the real task is deciding what you value. My biggest advice is simple: Get to know yourself. After you get to know yourself, figure out where people such as yourself like to gather physically. And, perhaps unexpectedly, you might find that social media and the internet can be wonderful tools to bridge our multifaceted ways of communicating. For example, people heading to major events like the Pokémon World Championships gathering in San Francisco either communicated online beforehand or used social media to maintain their connections afterward.
Finally, make a real effort to show up, and then keep on showing up. If you feel overwhelmed and daunted by real-life conversations, remember you do not actually have to be the one to initiate.
You just have to lead with a desire to connect authentically in the moment, rather than following a script. Just as you might not feel a spark in ordinary places, you might not feel it right away even in spaces meant to cultivate connection, like a run club or day party.
Continue to explore your interests and hobbies and find out ways to meet up with people who share them, keeping in mind that going from acquaintance to friends can take anywhere from a few weeks to a few years.
The rest will take care of itself.